Skip to content
Risk Management8 min read

How to Set Stop Loss and Take Profit: The Stop Comes First

One target, scaling out or a trailing stop. Each exit plan wins on some price paths and gives back on others. How each one works, how to write it before entry and a worked 1:3 example.

Chad Wittfeldt

Updated

Headline "Taking profit" beside a neon green rising chart with three target lines and a flag on the top one

The short version

Close or hold? You're already past your target

Close it or hold it? You're deep in profit, already past your take profit. You set that target before you entered. Price paid you what you planned for. Nothing on the chart has changed. Presented by Chad Wittfeldt's AI avatar, sharing lessons from the Crypto Renegades Mastermind.

Watch on YouTube

Most people plan the entry for an hour and the exit for zero minutes... then the position is green, the feed is loud, and the exit gets decided by whatever feels right that minute.

Taking profit in crypto means deciding before entry where and how a winning position will be closed. There are three main methods: one fixed target, scaling out at several levels, or a trailing stop that follows price. Each wins on some price paths and gives back on others, so the plan is written before the order, never improvised mid-trade.

So who's this for? If you've ever watched a winner turn into a loser because you "wanted to see where it goes," and you're done doing that, this is for you. If you're hunting for the exit that catches the exact top every time... that exit doesn't exist, and chasing it is how green trades turn red.

Influencer screenshots show the exit that worked. They never show the plan, because usually there wasn't one.

Why does the take-profit plan have to be written before you enter?

Because the exit sets the math of the trade. A risk-reward ratio is only real if the target is a level you'll actually exit at. Change the exit mid-trade and the ratio you checked before entry no longer describes the position you hold.

It's also the part of the trade most exposed to emotion. A Library of Congress report prepared for the SEC describes the disposition effect: "the tendency of investors to sell winning positions and to hold onto losing positions." Without a written exit, that tendency makes the decision for you.

The target itself comes from cause and effect: the setup is the cause, the move it can produce is the effect, and the two have to match. In my timeframe imposition lesson I put the rule this way: "I'm not going to be greedy with my take profits. I'm going to set my targets in congruence from the cause to the effect and trade in line with the higher timeframe." A pattern on the 15-minute chart doesn't carry a target from the weekly chart. Our crypto trading strategies guide explains how to size a target to the timeframe of the setup.

On a live call I put it to members this way: "Y'all a little greedy with your take profit? You had it in the right place and you think, man, this is the big one."

A written exit plan answers five questions:

  • Where are the targets? Levels from chart structure: a previous rejection, the far side of a range, the next higher-timeframe level. We mark these on the chart as areas of interest before the order goes in.
  • How much closes at each? All at one level, or a set share at each.
  • What happens to the stop after each exit? The stop is never widened, and it isn't moved early. It stays at the invalidation level until the trade is around 1 to 1.5R in profit, then it moves to break even first, and only once the trade runs further does it move into profit, anchored under confirmed structure such as the last higher low. The exact rule we teach is in the trailing stop section below.
  • What ends the trade early? A defined event, such as a full candle close back below the breakout level, or the break of the trendline the trade was built on.
  • What would justify holding past the target? Written down, or it doesn't apply.

One more thing the plan should say: how to read the reaction when price reaches an area of interest. If price blows through the level with a full-body close and keeps holding beyond it, that isn't where to take profits. If price halts at the level, pulls back and retests it, that's the signal to consider the first target. I like to see what type of reaction we get at a level before deciding what to do at it.

An exit you make up in the moment isn't an exit plan. It's a mood.

What are your three options for taking profit?

One target

The whole position closes at a single level. It's the simplest to execute and the most straightforward to review, and the ratio you planned is the ratio you get. The cost: if price turns just short of the target, the whole position rides back to the stop unless the plan says otherwise.

Scaling out

Part of the position closes at a first level and the rest at a further one. From our order-execution training: "You can only set one take profit at a time. But you can put visual targets, we call 'em areas of interest... when price gets into your target, you can close out partials." Scaling out banks part of the move early. The remainder needs a bigger move to pay its share.

Trailing stop

The stop follows price, usually just under each new higher low on a long. It lets a strong trend keep paying. The cost is that normal pullbacks can close the position early. My co-founder Niko Mercuris names the common error: "This is where most people make mistakes is they... prematurely move their stop-loss up and then boom, it comes back down and hits 'em and takes 'em out." We teach trailing by hand under confirmed structure, not with a tight automatic percentage. An automatic trailing stop set a few percent behind price is just another obvious stop, and it gets taken like one.

The house rule for moving it, in my own words: "go to break even around one to 1.5 risk to reward. The percentage doesn't matter, it's the risk unit versus the reward unit." Once the trade is around 1 to 1.5R in profit (1 to 1.5 times the amount risked), the stop moves to break even. Trailing it further into profit follows structure: each new stop sits under confirmed structure, the last higher low or the level that has become new support, never at a price picked for comfort.

One mechanical point applies to every trailing plan. As investor.gov puts it, "When the stop price is reached, a stop order becomes a market order." The fill can land beyond the level.

Three tools. None of them is magic. Each one just picks which mistake you'd rather live with.

How does each take-profit plan play out on the same 1:3 trade?

Here's the worked example, with our house numbers: a $50,000 account risking 1%, which is $500. One percent is where we start new traders, and it only rises when a month of closed trades supports a step up. The numbers are illustrative.

A hypothetical long on Ethereum. The 4-hour chart has equal lows at $2,450. Price sweeps them to $2,430, taking the stops underneath, then closes back above the lows. The entry is $2,500 on the reclaim, where everybody else is getting stopped out. The thesis is wrong below the low of that sweep, so the stop goes at $2,420: $80 per coin. Size comes from the stop: $500 ÷ $80 = 6.25 ETH, a position of about $15,625. The next resistance, a previous rejection, sits at $2,740. That's $240 above entry, three times the stop distance. A 1:3 setup, and it clears the 1:3 filter: no trade under one to three.

Three written plans for the same trade:

  • Plan A, one target. Close all 6.25 ETH at $2,740.
  • Plan B, scale out. Close half at $2,660, a minor level, and hold the other half for $2,820, the next higher level. The stop on the remaining half stays at $2,420.
  • Plan C, trailing. The stop is never widened. It stays at $2,420 until the trade is around 1 to 1.5R in profit ($2,580 to $2,620), then moves to break even at $2,500. Once price has run further and printed a higher low that holds, it moves into profit, just under that higher low, with room left for price to oscillate.

Plan B keeps the ratio honest. The average of its two exits is $2,740, the same 1:3 as Plan A.

Now three ways price can move after entry:

  1. It stalls. Price reaches $2,700, pulls back to a higher low at $2,610, bounces, then falls all the way to $2,420.
  2. It shakes out, then runs. Price reaches $2,700, pulls back to a higher low at $2,610, wicks briefly to $2,595, then runs past $2,900.
  3. It trends. Price climbs in steps to $3,000. The last higher low before it turns is $2,860.
Price path Plan A: one target Plan B: scale out Plan C: trailing
1. Stalls -$500 (-1R) +$250 (+0.5R) +$625 (+1.25R)
2. Shakes out, then runs +$1,500 (+3R) +$1,500 (+3R) +$625 (+1.25R)
3. Trends +$1,500 (+3R) +$1,500 (+3R) +$2,188 (+4.4R)

All figures are before fees and slippage. Plan C moves to break even once price trades around $2,580 to $2,620 (1 to 1.5R), then sits at $2,600 under the $2,610 higher low in paths 1 and 2, and at $2,850 under the $2,860 higher low in path 3.

No plan wins every path. One target gives the cleanest ratio and the worst result when price stalls. Scaling out is rarely the best and rarely the worst. Trailing captures the trend and gets shaken out by noise.

Same entry, same stop, same size. The only variable was the exit, and it was decided before the order. That's the WHOLE lesson right there.

How do you pick the take-profit plan that fits you?

Pick the plan whose bad path you can accept, then use it consistently. Change methods trade by trade and your journal can't tell you which one works for you, right?

  • Match the chart. One clean level ahead suits one target. Several stacked levels suit scaling out. A clear trend with defined higher lows suits a trail.
  • Match the timeframe. Short intraday trades rarely have room to trail. Swing trades often do. For what it's worth, I like to position in on some decent sized moves. I don't really like trading those small moves. Our swing trading training is blunt about the hard part: "The name of the game with swing trading, just keep your finger off the button."
  • Match your habits. If you tend to close early when a position goes green, a written scale-out gives you a planned early exit instead of an impulsive one.

The best exit plan on paper is worthless if you bail on it halfway through the trade.

What can a take-profit plan never do?

A take-profit plan can't find the top. Every plan leaves something on the table on some path, and the chart will show it to you afterward. You're going to leave a little licorice on the table. And that's fine. That's the cost of having a plan, not a flaw in it.

A target is a level, not a promise that price will reach it. Stops fill as market orders and can slip in a fast market. Fees come out of every exit, and scaling out means more of them.

Every member makes their own decisions with their own capital. We review the process behind those decisions. We never manage anyone's capital.

At the end of the day, the money you leave on the table is the price of a plan you can repeat.

What should you dig up this week?

Take your last ten closed positions and write down which exit plan each one actually used, and whether it was written before entry. Most people find out they've been running a fourth plan: "whatever I felt like."

Want your exit plans reviewed live? See how the Mastermind works, then Apply for the Mastermind.

This is education, not financial or investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

  • Write the exit before the entry. Pick the target levels from chart structure, decide how much of the position closes at each one and what the stop does after each exit, then follow that plan instead of the feeling in the moment. On a 1:3 setup that means knowing, before you click, whether you're closing it all at 3R, scaling out on the way or trailing under structure.

  • At the levels written in your plan before entry, taken from chart structure such as a previous rejection or the next higher-timeframe level. Exiting wherever it feels right in the moment tends to mean closing good positions early and holding poor ones too long.

  • Neither does best every time. One target keeps the planned ratio intact but gives everything back if price stalls short of it. Scaling out banks part early and smooths results, but the remaining part needs a bigger move. Choose the one whose bad case you can accept and use it consistently.

  • A trailing stop suits trending markets with clear higher lows on a long, or lower highs on a short. Set too tight, normal pullbacks close the position early. Trail by hand under confirmed structure rather than with a tight automatic percentage: break even first once the trade is around 1 to 1.5R in profit, then into profit behind the last higher low, and remember a triggered stop becomes a market order.

  • Only if the plan written before entry says when and why. Pulling a target to let a position run is a new decision made under the influence of an open position, and it often ends with price retracing to where the original target would have closed it.

Sources

  1. Investor.gov: Types of orders (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission)
  2. Behavioral Patterns and Pitfalls of U.S. Investors (Library of Congress, prepared for the SEC, 2010)

General education only, not financial advice. Crypto and leverage involve substantial risk of loss. Read our risk disclosure.

Written by

Chad Wittfeldt

Co-Founder and Strategy Lead, Crypto Renegades

Chad first heard about Bitcoin in 2012, bought his first coin in 2013 at around $100, learned markets through forex in 2015 and went full time on crypto in 2017, posting public technical analysis on Bitcoin's break above $3,000 that August. That same year he flagged USI Tech and BitConnect as Ponzi schemes and warned the people around him before either one was exposed. He ran an Ethereum GPU mining operation from 2019 to 2021, and verification runs through everything he teaches.

Stop borrowing opinions. Build a process you own.

Every course, in the order we teach it, and a community of people learning the same process. Try the Crypto Renegades Skool Community free for a week, then $97/month.