Skip to content

Proof of reserves: a nice gesture, but a single pane of glass

Proof of reserves shows the coins in an exchange's wallets at one moment. It doesn't show what the company owes or the leverage it carries. Here's how it works and what to check.

Chad Wittfeldt

Updated

Headline "Proof of reserves" beside a neon green glass pane showing a stack of blank coins, the space behind it empty

Proof of reserves is a nice gesture from an exchange, but it's a single pane of glass. It shows you the coins sitting in the company's wallets at one moment in time. It doesn't show you everything the company owes, and it doesn't show you the leverage it has outstanding. That's the part that sinks exchanges.

Every time an exchange gets into trouble, the same thing happens. Everybody rushes to publish a reserves page, the green checkmarks come out, and people relax. And I understand why... a number with a lot of zeros on it feels like safety.

Some of you want to know what a reserves report actually proves before you decide how much to leave on a platform, and you're in the right place. Others want a checkmark so they can stop thinking about custody, and if that's you, I'm going to talk you out of it.

What is proof of reserves, in plain English?

Proof of reserves is a report in which a crypto exchange or custodian shows that it holds enough assets to cover the customer balances it reports. It has two halves. The asset side shows wallets the company controls, usually proven by signing a message with those wallets or by having an outside firm check them. The customer side shows a list of every user balance, rolled into a single number.

If the coins in the wallets are equal to or greater than the customer balances, the report says the exchange is "fully backed." That's the claim. But the way the report gets built is where the limits come from.

How does a proof of reserves Merkle tree work?

Most exchanges use a Merkle tree for the customer side, and the idea is simpler than the name.

Each customer's ID and balance gets run through a hash function, which turns it into a fixed string of characters. Those hashes get paired up and hashed again, over and over, until one final hash is left, called the root. The exchange publishes the root and the total. Each customer can then take their own balance plus a short list of neighboring hashes and rebuild the root themselves. If it matches, your balance was counted. If it doesn't, something is wrong.

It's clever, right? It lets you check that you're included without seeing anyone else's balance. But notice what the customer did there. You confirmed that you're in the list. You didn't confirm the list is complete, and you didn't confirm what else the company owes outside of it.

And the whole thing is a snapshot. It's true for the moment it was taken. The next morning, the coins can be lent out, moved or pledged as collateral, and the report would still look exactly the same.

Is a proof of reserves audit the same as a real audit?

No, and this is where the marketing gets ahead of the facts. A lot of people say "proof of reserves audit" when what they're looking at is an attestation, a narrower check of specific things the company asked an outside firm to look at.

On March 8, 2023, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, the US regulator that oversees auditors of public companies, warned investors directly. Its advisory said "PoR engagements are not audits," that the procedures "likely do not address the crypto entity's liabilities," that the reports give no assurance about internal controls or governance, and that investors "should exercise extreme caution when relying on them." A few months earlier, in December 2022, the accounting firm that had produced reserve reports for several large exchanges paused all of its crypto work.

A full financial audit looks at both sides of the balance sheet, meaning everything the company owns and everything it owes, plus its controls. A reserves report looks at one side, at one moment. That's the real difference, and anyone calling the second one an audit is selling you comfort.

What doesn't proof of reserves show you?

Here's the list that matters, because these are the gaps where exchanges have actually failed:

  • Liabilities beyond the customer list. Loans the company took, money owed to lenders and partners, and any debts that aren't customer balances don't show up.
  • Outstanding leverage. If the company has borrowed against its holdings or is carrying big leveraged positions, the snapshot won't tell you.
  • Borrowed coins. Assets can be borrowed for the day of the snapshot and returned the next, and the regulator's advisory flagged exactly that.
  • What happens after the snapshot. The report is true for one moment, and the risk lives in all the moments after it.
  • Accounts left out. Negative balances or accounts the company chose not to include can make the total look healthier than it is.

So the honest read of a clean report is that on that date, the coins in those wallets were there. That's useful. It just ISN'T the same as "this company can pay everyone back."

Could FTX have passed a proof of reserves check?

I think FTX likely could have shown impressive reserves, right up until it couldn't.

FTX filed for bankruptcy on November 11, 2022. The next day, the Financial Times reported that, on the eve of the filing, FTX had about $9 billion in liabilities and only about $900 million in assets that could be sold quickly. Most of its other recorded assets were hard to sell, like venture investments and thinly traded tokens. Show the asset side by itself, on a good day, with a big enough stack of tokens in the wallets, and the screen looks strong. The hole was in what it owed and what it had done with customer money, and that's the side a reserves page doesn't show.

Now, I can tell you how that week looked from our side. When FTX went down in November 2022, nothing major happened to our members, because they were already trading from self custody wallets. And I'd been preaching "not your keys, not your crypto" long before that week.

That's my whole point about the single pane of glass. FTX wasn't missing assets on a screen. It was missing the full picture behind the screen.

What should you check in an exchange's proof of reserves?

If you're going to use one, use it properly. Here's what I'd look at:

  1. How often it's published. Monthly beats once a year, and a report from last spring tells you nothing about today.
  2. Who did the work and what kind of work it was. An outside firm's attestation is better than a self-published chart, and neither is a full audit.
  3. Whether you can verify your own balance. Find your account in the Merkle tree and rebuild the root. If the exchange doesn't let you, ask why.
  4. Which coins are covered. A report on two coins says nothing about the other forty you might hold there.
  5. Whether liabilities are addressed at all. If there's no mention of what the company owes beyond customer balances, the report can't answer the solvency question.

After its October 29, 2026 hack, Binance said it would publish an updated proof of reserves once remediation is done. That's worth reading when it lands. Just read it for what it is, which is a snapshot of one side of the ledger.

Should proof of reserves change where you keep your crypto?

It should, but only a little. A clean report can help you choose between exchanges for the money you're actively trading. It can't make an exchange the right place for money you plan to hold for years.

The coins you don't trade belong in self custody, where the only reserves that matter are the ones you can check yourself, any time, on your own device. I walk through the setup, the test sends and the custody split in how to self custody crypto, and the trade-offs between wallet types are in hot wallet vs cold wallet. If you want the full story of the hack that made this topic urgent again, it's in our Binance hack breakdown.

What do you do with a proof of reserves report this week?

Open the reserves page of every exchange you use and answer the five questions above in writing. Then add up what you keep on each one. If the number on any single platform would keep you up at night, move what you aren't trading.

Reading past the checkmark is the whole difference between the person who trusts it and the person who knows what it covers. If you want to learn custody and risk with coaches checking your work, try our Skool Community free for a week, then $97/month.

This is education, not financial advice. A reserves report describes one company at one moment, and facts here are current as of November 3, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

  • Proof of reserves is a report in which a crypto exchange or custodian shows that the assets in its wallets cover the customer balances it reports, at one moment in time. It usually pairs proof that the company controls certain wallets with a Merkle tree of customer balances that each user can check.

  • No. The PCAOB said in its March 8, 2023 investor advisory that proof of reserve engagements are not audits, that they likely do not address a company's liabilities, and that they give no assurance about internal controls or governance.

  • It doesn't show liabilities beyond the customer balances the exchange chose to include, outstanding leverage, whether assets were borrowed for the snapshot, or what happened to the coins after the snapshot was taken.

  • Use the exchange's verification tool to get your own hashed record and the Merkle path, then rebuild the root and compare it with the published root. A match means your balance was included in that snapshot. It doesn't prove the list was complete.

Sources

  1. PCAOB Investor Advisory: Exercise caution with third-party verification/proof of reserve reports (Mar 8, 2023)
  2. CNBC: Mazars suspends all work with crypto clients (Dec 16, 2022)
  3. The Block: FTX had only $900 million in liquid assets backing $9 billion in debt, FT (Nov 12, 2022)
  4. BNN Bloomberg: FTX Trading's liabilities dwarfed liquid assets, FT says
  5. Bitcoin Companies: Merkle tree proof of reserves explained
  6. ABC7: Binance estimates security breach impact at $6.3 billion (Oct 2026)

General education only, not financial advice. Crypto and leverage involve substantial risk of loss. Read our risk disclosure.

Written by

Chad Wittfeldt

Co-Founder and Strategy Lead, Crypto Renegades

Chad first heard about Bitcoin in 2012, bought his first coin in 2013 at around $100, learned markets through forex in 2015 and went full time on crypto in 2017, posting public technical analysis on Bitcoin's break above $3,000 that August. That same year he flagged USI Tech and BitConnect as Ponzi schemes and warned the people around him before either one was exposed. He ran an Ethereum GPU mining operation from 2019 to 2021, and verification runs through everything he teaches.

Stop borrowing opinions. Build a process you own.

Every course, in the order we teach it, and a community of people learning the same process. Try the Crypto Renegades Skool Community free for a week, then $97/month.